GMH June FC / Dispatch Abnormal Order Monthly Report
Responsibility review based on TSV records, WhatsApp group logs, backend screenshots, and original image evidence. The report separates real screenshots, backend screenshots, image proof, and text evidence cards, so cases without images are not presented as screenshot-backed evidence.
Generated on 2026-07-02. Suggested meeting flow: start from P0 cases and ask owner-by-owner.
Executive Summary
After the 08:55 service time, FC did not actively monitor the waiting period. The same order shows no-show at 10:39 and drop-off at 10:40.
The driver did not complete arrival or service, dispatch did not detect it during service time, and later proof integrity broke down.
On 12 June, the team already knew there were 8 passengers, 8 large suitcases, and 4 carry-ons and judged that an 18-seater was needed. The order still proceeded into an on-site failure.
After multiple driver changes before service, the final vehicle type was not verified. The customer paid for a 7-seater service that was not fulfilled.
High-seat vehicle orders had no pre-service vehicle-card verification, and backend did not send vehicle information to the customer in advance.
Driver-customer meeting failed, Josua confirmed no proof, and the case ended with a full refund.
The customer tried to confirm the time the day before. Backend notes state the driver checked the wrong time, which is a clear dispatch and driver execution failure.
Responsibility Matrix
| Level | Order | Issue | Responsibility Chain | Meeting Action |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| P0 | 1049963 Heycar |
FC missed follow-up plus backend status conflict | FC / Shi Wei, with backend status recorder involved | Direct accountability |
| P0 | 1051886 Heycar |
Driver no-arrival, dispatch missed it, fake proof risk | Dispatch Veron / Anissa, new call-log recorder, driver involved | Direct accountability |
| P0 | 1050812 Heycar |
Known luggage and vehicle-capacity risk was not closed | OP / Support / dispatch assignment chain | Direct accountability |
| P0 | 1051140 Klook |
Five driver changes plus wrong vehicle type | Ong Kar Sing / dispatch assignment chain | Direct accountability |
| P0 | 1052140 Klook |
18-seater order was served by 9-seater vehicle | Dispatch / fleet assignment chain | Direct accountability |
| P0 | 1049534 kkday |
Internal dispatch arrangement issue, no proof at all | Dispatch, Josua / Wendy handling chain | Direct accountability |
| P0 | 1049065 Klook |
Driver checked wrong time, temporary rescue arranged | Driver / dispatch assignment chain, Joshua handling chain | Direct accountability |
| P1 | 1049832 Heytrip |
Chatroom or notification delivery failure plus no-contact proof | OP notification chain / duty dispatch | Timed proof supplement |
| P1 | 1045886 kkday |
Trip change was not reconfirmed, driver went to wrong hotel | Steven / OP confirmation chain, driver and dispatch involved | Timed proof supplement |
| P1 | 1049436 Klook |
Terminal and driver-info delivery failure | OP / dispatch / driver communication chain | Timed proof supplement |
| P1 | 1050451 Klook |
Driver details were not effectively delivered in time | OP / Support / dispatch | Timed proof supplement |
| P2 | 1049144 Heycar |
No-show evidence is strong, but upload process was blocked | OP / backend upload process | Process remediation |
| P2 | 1047852 Heytrip |
Service completed, initial proof was incomplete | Driver / OP proof-upload chain | Process remediation |
| P2 | 1048663 Klook-Sabah |
Arrival proof is strong, system notification issue is clear | IT / notification system, OP evidence chain involved | Process remediation |
| P1 | 1049409 Klook |
SUV order received large vehicle, dispatch still pending | Dispatch / Ong Kar Sing chain | Timed proof supplement |
| P1 | 1053406 Klook |
Late pickup followed by fueling, still waiting for driver reply | Driver / dispatch monitoring chain | Timed proof supplement |
P0 Direct Accountability Cases
1049963 - FC missed follow-up plus backend status conflict
Complete Timeline
Root Cause
After the 08:55 service time, FC did not actively monitor the waiting period. The same order shows no-show at 10:39 and drop-off at 10:40.
Failure Type
- Operational failure: customer was contacted near overtime only
- Work failure: driver request was not handled in time
- Process failure: backend statuses conflict
Meeting Questions
- Who monitored this order from 08:55 to 10:18?
- Why did the driver say no one responded at 10:23?
- Who wrote no-show and drop-off for the same order?
Marked Evidence
1051886 - Driver no-arrival, dispatch missed it, fake proof risk
Complete Timeline
Root Cause
The driver did not complete arrival or service, dispatch did not detect it during service time, and later proof integrity broke down.
Failure Type
- Operational failure: driver no-arrival was not detected
- Work failure: replacement vehicle was arranged too late
- Risk-control failure: fake proof discussion damaged appeal credibility
Meeting Questions
- Who covered Veron during lunch?
- Why did Anissa miss the driver's no-arrival?
- Who uploaded the fake proof and who approved it?
1050812 - Known luggage and vehicle-capacity risk was not closed
Complete Timeline
Root Cause
On 12 June, the team already knew there were 8 passengers, 8 large suitcases, and 4 carry-ons and judged that an 18-seater was needed. The order still proceeded into an on-site failure.
Failure Type
- Work failure: known risk was not owned to closure
- Process failure: no open-risk status before service
- Complaint-handling failure: customer was told to solve it on-site
Meeting Questions
- Who owned the 18-seater upgrade follow-up on 12 June?
- Why did the order proceed when the customer did not confirm?
- Why was there no split-car or upgrade plan before service?
Marked Evidence
1051140 - Five driver changes plus wrong vehicle type
Complete Timeline
Root Cause
After multiple driver changes before service, the final vehicle type was not verified. The customer paid for a 7-seater service that was not fulfilled.
Failure Type
- Work failure: fleet lead assigned wrong vehicle type
- Process failure: repeated driver changes had no supervisor review
- Evidence failure: order folder is empty
Meeting Questions
- Who made each of the five driver changes?
- Who verified the final vehicle type?
- Why are there no vehicle card and vehicle photos?
1052140 - 18-seater order was served by 9-seater vehicle
Complete Timeline
Root Cause
High-seat vehicle orders had no pre-service vehicle-card verification, and backend did not send vehicle information to the customer in advance.
Failure Type
- Work failure: vehicle type mismatch
- Process failure: vehicle card unavailable
- Evidence failure: folder is empty
Meeting Questions
- Why did an 18-seater order receive a 9-seater vehicle?
- Why was the vehicle card unavailable?
- Who allowed the platform reply without vehicle-card proof?
1049534 - Internal dispatch arrangement issue, no proof at all
Complete Timeline
Root Cause
Driver-customer meeting failed, Josua confirmed no proof, and the case ended with a full refund.
Failure Type
- Work failure: pickup meeting failed
- Process failure: no proof led to full refund
- Evidence failure: no order folder exists
Meeting Questions
- Why was there no incident report?
- Where did the driver park and who verified it?
- Why did the issue only close at refund stage?
1049065 - Driver checked wrong time, temporary rescue arranged
Complete Timeline
Root Cause
The customer tried to confirm the time the day before. Backend notes state the driver checked the wrong time, which is a clear dispatch and driver execution failure.
Failure Type
- Operational failure: driver checked wrong time
- Work failure: temporary arrangement damaged experience
- Process failure: pickup-time confirmation did not close
Meeting Questions
- Why were 05:00 and 07:15 not reconfirmed?
- When was the temporary driver arranged?
- Who bears the 30 percent refund?
P1 Timed Proof Supplement Cases
1049832 - Chatroom or notification delivery failure plus no-contact proof
Complete Timeline
Root Cause
Driver and vehicle waiting proof exists, but chat link or notification delivery appears late. Dispatch must provide email/chat-link sending logs and platform contact records.
Failure Type
- Process failure: notification chain broke
- Evidence failure: contact records were saved only after the issue
Meeting Questions
- What did the customer receive before 20:30?
- Where are the email/chat-link sending logs?
- Where are platform-assisted contact records?
Marked Evidence
1045886 - Trip change was not reconfirmed, driver went to wrong hotel
Complete Timeline
Root Cause
Sky Mirror cancellation, date-change or refund handling, wrong pickup point, and no response were connected. It cannot be explained only by customer non-reply.
Failure Type
- Work failure: Steven did not reconfirm
- Operational failure: driver went to wrong hotel
- Process failure: refund and trip-change handling did not close
Meeting Questions
- When was Steven's last confirmation?
- Why did the driver go to the wrong hotel?
- Who owned the refund request?
1049436 - Terminal and driver-info delivery failure
Complete Timeline
Root Cause
Vehicle photos show arrival, but the customer said driver details were not received before arrival and they waited at T1 Gate 4 before leaving.
Failure Type
- Process failure: driver details were delivered too late
- Work failure: T1/T2 pickup-point mismatch was not resolved
- Evidence failure: pre-no-show communication chain incomplete
Meeting Questions
- When were driver details sent to the customer?
- Was the driver actually at T1 or T2?
- Was the pickup-point mismatch solved before no-show?
Marked Evidence
1050451 - Driver details were not effectively delivered in time
Complete Timeline
Root Cause
An email was sent, but that does not prove the customer effectively received it. The customer still asked 39 minutes before service, and Support pasted driver details at 09:25.
Failure Type
- Work failure: pre-service communication was slow
- Process failure: no confirmation after email sending
- Service-experience failure: customer had to chase before pickup
Meeting Questions
- Was there WhatsApp confirmation after the 10 June email?
- Why did the customer have to ask at 09:21?
- Where is the driver's private-contact record?
1049409 - SUV order received large vehicle, dispatch still pending
Complete Timeline
Root Cause
Customer clearly complained that a 7-8 seater SUV became a large 18-seater vehicle, with poor driving experience.
Failure Type
- Work failure: likely vehicle mismatch
- Process failure: dispatch investigation not closed
Meeting Questions
- Where is the actual vehicle image?
- Where are driver and vehicle card records?
- Will vehicle mismatch be compensated?
1053406 - Late pickup followed by fueling, still waiting for driver reply
Complete Timeline
Root Cause
Late pickup plus fueling after pickup points to driver preparation and dispatch monitoring problems. It must not remain pending.
Failure Type
- Operational failure: late pickup
- Work failure: pre-trip fuel preparation missing
- Process failure: dispatch did not quickly close investigation
Meeting Questions
- What caused driver lateness?
- Why did the driver refuel after picking up the customer?
- Did the customer arrive at the airport on time?
P2 Process Remediation Cases
1049144 - No-show evidence is strong, but upload process was blocked
Complete Timeline
Root Cause
Driver arrival and repeated calls are supported by evidence. The main issue is unstable proof upload, account use, and filing path.
Failure Type
- Evidence failure: photos could not be uploaded to backend
- Process failure: temporary account switching was needed
Meeting Questions
- Why could the backend not paste or upload photos?
- Who owns the unified upload path?
- What is the SLA for placing proof into the order folder?
Marked Evidence
1047852 - Service completed, initial proof was incomplete
Complete Timeline
Root Cause
Luggage loading and drop-off proof exist. The focus should be why airport-arrival proof needed to be supplemented later.
Failure Type
- Evidence failure: initial upload was incomplete
- Process failure: proof was supplemented only after platform chase
Meeting Questions
- Why was airport-arrival proof not uploaded first?
- Who checked proof completeness?
- What is the proof supplement SLA?
1048663 - Arrival proof is strong, system notification issue is clear
Complete Timeline
Root Cause
Driver arrived at 21:25 and made multiple contact attempts. TSV states email notification sync failed from 29 to 31 May.
Failure Type
- System failure: email notification did not sync
- Evidence failure: system logs proving customer non-receipt must be added
Meeting Questions
- How many orders were impacted by the system issue?
- Was there an incident notice and recovery action?
- How are customers contacted when they have no WhatsApp?
Evidence Gaps to Challenge in the Meeting
- Every abnormal order must have a unified order folder. Evidence cannot remain only in live chat, WhatsApp, personal accounts, or platform backend.
- No-show, vehicle mismatch, driver no-arrival, and customer no-contact cases must have a standard evidence pack: GPS arrival, vehicle card or plate, contact log, waiting-end record, and backend status.
- Any discussion involving fake proof or fabricated appeal must be escalated as a risk-control incident, not handled as normal proof supplement.
















